One of the most common questions we get asked by incorporated business owners is "how should I pay myself?" On the surface, this is a simple enough question; there are two main options for owner compensation: salary and dividends. It's not as simple as deciding between the two though. You need to know how much cash you need to live on, what your business can afford, what your business & personal financial objectives are, and many other considerations. Paying the least amount of tax possible is often not the main driver in owner compensation discussions.
Salary vs Dividends
Most owners want to know if paying themselves via salary or dividends will result in the lowest tax bill. If you look at personal tax rate tables online, you might see lower personal tax rates on dividends, but that is only part of the picture. Essentially, a dividend is a distribution from the company’s pool of accumulated after-tax profits; it is therefore not a business expense. Salary on the other hand is a business expense, and can reduce corporate taxable income. To compare the overall tax cost of salary vs dividends fairly, you need to look at both corporate and personal taxes.
Let's look at an example where an owner wants to pay themselves $100,000 from their corporation. For this example, we’re using a Nova Scotia corporation paying the small business rate of tax and an owner based in Nova Scotia. It uses 2026 tax rates and assumes a type of dividend called non-eligible dividends.
$100,000 Salary vs. Dividend Tax Comparison
| Comparison | Salary | Dividends |
|---|---|---|
| Amount paid to owner | $100,000 | $100,000 |
| Personal income tax | $25,619 | $20,650 |
| Employee CPP contributions | $4,646 | $0 |
| Owner's after-tax cash | $69,734 | $79,350 |
| Employer CPP contributions | $4,646 | $0 |
| Corporate tax deduction (salary + employer CPP) | $104,646 | $0 |
| Corporate income tax savings from deduction | $10,988 | $0 |
| Corporate income tax required to fund payment* | $0 | $11,732 |
| Total personal and corporate taxes | $25,619 | $32,382 |
| Total taxes and CPP (both portions) | $34,912 | $32,382 |
| Combined effective tax and CPP rate | 33.4% | 29.0% |
*At a 10.5% corporate income tax rate, approximately $111,732 in pre-tax corporate earnings is needed to fund a $100,000 dividend.
You'll see from the example above that the amount of tax you pay with salary vs dividends is similar. But if dividends sometimes result in lower personal tax, why might an owner still choose to pay themselves a salary?
Why the lowest tax bill isn't the only objective
The tax comparison is only one piece of the decision. Paying yourself a salary can create a number of other benefits and tax planning opportunities that shouldn't be ignored.
Banks generally prefer salary income vs dividend income when looking at financing applications from small business owners (even when it is the same amount and coming from the same place), salaries create future CPP benefits that can be drawn on, and if you want to contribute to an RRSP as part of your retirement savings strategy, you need to pay yourself at least some salary to generate contribution room.
You also need to consider things like whether your business can afford regular payroll plus the taxes & CPP that need to be remitted monthly, or how much after-tax cash you need to cover your personal bills. If you need $5,000 a month to live on and take cash dividends of $60,000 for the year, you'll be disappointed come tax time when you are looking at an $8,000 personal tax bill with no cash in the bank to cover it. Likewise, if you pay yourself so much that it causes your business to start having cash problems, you may create larger issues within your business.
The table below walks through the qualitative factors of compensation planning and how they differ between salary and dividends.
| Consideration | Salary | Dividends |
|---|---|---|
| CPP contributions | Employee and employer CPP contributions generally required | No CPP contributions required |
| CPP retirement benefits | Builds CPP retirement benefits, including potential disability and survivor benefits for if something should happen to you | Does not build CPP entitlements |
| RRSP contribution room | Creates RRSP room, generally 18% of earned income up to the annual limit | Does not create any RRSP contribution room |
| Mortgages and financing | Regular salary on a T4 is preferred by bigger lenders, and simplifies documentation provided with application | Less favourable to bigger lenders, and may require additional history and corporate financial documentation |
| Income stability | Regular payroll provides predictable personal cash flow | Can be paid periodically or when corporate cash flow permits |
| Administrative requirements | Requires payroll processing, source deductions, remittances and T4 reporting | Generally simpler administration; requires proper corporate authorization and T5 reporting |
| Employment Insurance (EI) | Generally not available to business owners; special benefits may be available through voluntary registration | Does not create insurable employment or EI eligibility |
| Retirement planning flexibility | Supports RRSP accumulation and potentially an Individual Pension Plan (IPP) | Avoids mandatory CPP contributions, allowing owners to invest the difference independently |
| Corporate cash flow | Employer CPP adds a cash cost; payroll remittances must be made regularly | No employer CPP; dividend payments can be timed around available after-tax cash |
| Tax planning flexibility | Salary or bonuses can help reduce corporate taxable income | Dividends can provide flexibility in distributing accumulated after-tax corporate profits |
| Best suited for | Owners prioritizing retirement benefits, RRSP savings, predictable income or borrowing documentation | Owners prioritizing immediate cash flow, flexibility and avoiding CPP contributions |
Compensation planning is an annual exercise
Compensation planning shouldn't be a set it and forget it exercise. It needs to be evaluated at least once a year to ensure that your compensation is a good fit for your business and personal circumstances as your life and your business change and evolve over time.
When you are starting your compensation planning each year, ask yourself:
What amount of personal income do I need to cover expenses, contribute to personal savings, and budget for any fun stuff like nights out or family vacations?
What can my business actually afford without creating a net loss or cash flow problems?
What are my personal and retirement savings objectives?
Will I be making a personal financing application (mortgage or other debt) in the next few years?
Having answers to these questions will give you a pretty good starting point for a conversation with your accountant or financial planner on how to best compensate yourself from your business.
And if the answers to any of those questions change throughout the year, make sure to look at changing the plan! Like any good plan, your compensation plan should be flexible enough to adapt to changing circumstances as needed.
Bright Line compensation planning
What does Bright Line typically recommend? There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but here are are few things we think owners should consider as they plan their compensation:
Pay themselves an amount that their business can afford and that covers their basic personal needs. Whether this is salary or dividends depends on the company's cash flow and profitability.
Consider whether salary sufficient to maximize CPP contributions is appropriate (the 2027 first-tier earnings ceiling is $76,700 and the second-tier CPP2 ceiling is $87,400).
Consider how much salary is needed to generate desired RRSP room. For the 2027 RRSP dollar limit of $35,390, approximately $196,611 of 2026 earned income would generate the maximum new room for 2027.
Take dividends when there is excess profit that doesn't need to be reinvested in the business or used to pay down corporate tax/financing liabilities.
The above points are very generalized and need to be filtered through the lens of each business owner's unique circumstances. They also don't factor in what stage of life both a business and its owner are in.
So, how much should I pay myself?
Let's go back to the question of "how should I pay myself?" After reading through the above, it should be clear that:
Everyone's compensation plan is unique and varies based on their specific circumstances, challenges, and objectives.
You should pay yourself what your business can afford.
Your compensation plan shouldn't be solely focused on reducing personal taxes.
Your compensation should be evaluated at least once a year.
Your compensation plan will change over time as you and your business go through various stages of life.
For many owners, the right approach likely involves a combination of salary and dividends.
Not sure whether your current compensation approach still works for you and your business? We are preparing a free owner compensation guide that goes much deeper into all of the points above, as well as into more complex compensation planning strategies and opportunities. Join our mailing list to be notified when it becomes available!